A Pennsylvania Guide to Serving as a Fiduciary

Download this guide as a PDF

Keep it for reference or share it with family members.

Download PDF →

What Is a Fiduciary?

A fiduciary is someone who manages money, property, or decisions on behalf of another person. In Pennsylvania, the most common fiduciary roles are executor (personal representative), trustee, agent under a durable power of attorney, and healthcare agent under a healthcare power of attorney.

What connects all four roles is a legal standard called the fiduciary duty — the obligation to act in the best interests of the person you serve, not your own. This duty has three components that apply across all fiduciary roles:

Duty of loyalty: You must put the beneficiary's interests ahead of your own. You cannot self-deal, favor one beneficiary over another without legal authority, or use your position for personal benefit.

Duty of care: You must act with the same care and diligence that a reasonable person would use in managing their own affairs. Negligence — even unintentional — can result in personal liability.

Duty to account: You must keep detailed records of every financial decision, transaction, and distribution. Beneficiaries and courts can demand an accounting at any time, and gaps in your records will be held against you.

Executor / Personal Representative

An executor (called a "personal representative" in some contexts) is the person named in a will to manage the decedent's estate through the probate process. If there is no will, the court appoints an administrator who has essentially the same duties.

How You're Appointed

You are not automatically the executor just because the will names you. You must file the original will with the Register of Wills in the county where the decedent lived and petition for Letters Testamentary. The Register issues "Short Certificates" — the official documents proving your authority to act. Most institutions require original Short Certificates before they will release information or assets.

Your Core Duties

Secure and inventory assets. Immediately after appointment, you must identify, locate, and protect all estate assets — real property, bank accounts, investment accounts, personal property, vehicles, digital assets, and business interests. You must file a formal inventory with the Register of Wills.

Publish notice to creditors. Pennsylvania law requires you to advertise the estate in a newspaper of general circulation and the county legal journal. This starts the one-year creditor claim period under 20 Pa.C.S. § 3532.

Pay debts and expenses. You must pay legitimate creditor claims, funeral expenses, and estate administration costs in the order of priority established by Pennsylvania law. Paying debts out of order can make you personally liable to higher-priority creditors.

File tax returns. You are responsible for the decedent's final income tax return (federal and state), the Pennsylvania inheritance tax return (REV-1500, due within 9 months of death with a 5% discount if paid within 3 months), and the estate's income tax return if the estate earns income during administration.

Distribute assets. After debts, taxes, and expenses are paid, you distribute the remaining assets according to the will's terms. You should obtain signed receipts and releases from all beneficiaries before making final distributions.

Key Deadlines

Pennsylvania inheritance tax is due 9 months after the date of death (with a 5% discount for payment within 3 months). The decedent's final federal income tax return is due April 15 of the year after death. There is no strict deadline for completing administration, but most estates should be settled within 12 to 18 months.

Trustee

A trustee manages assets held in a trust for the benefit of one or more beneficiaries. You may become a trustee because you were named as successor trustee in a family member's revocable living trust (which becomes irrevocable at their death) or because you were named as trustee of a standalone irrevocable trust.

Your Core Duties

Administer according to the trust terms. The trust document is your governing authority. You must follow its terms regarding investments, distributions, and termination — not your own judgment about what would be "fair" or "better." If the trust says distribute income quarterly to the surviving spouse, you distribute income quarterly to the surviving spouse.

Prudent investment. Pennsylvania adopted the Uniform Prudent Investor Act (20 Pa.C.S. § 7203), which requires you to invest trust assets as a prudent investor would — diversified, risk-appropriate, and consistent with the trust's purposes. Leaving trust assets in a non-interest-bearing checking account for months can be a breach of this duty.

Impartiality. If the trust has multiple beneficiaries (for example, income to the surviving spouse and remainder to children), you must balance the interests of current and future beneficiaries. Favoring one group over the other is a breach of duty.

Accounting and transparency. Beneficiaries are entitled to information about the trust. Pennsylvania law requires trustees to provide accountings upon reasonable request. You should maintain detailed records of all receipts, disbursements, and investment decisions from day one.

Tax compliance. Irrevocable trusts have their own tax ID number and must file annual income tax returns (federal Form 1041 and PA-41). Trust income tax rates reach the highest bracket much faster than individual rates, making timely distributions to beneficiaries a significant tax planning consideration.

Common Pitfalls

Commingling trust assets with personal funds, failing to diversify investments, making distributions without documentation, and ignoring the trust's specific terms are the most common trustee mistakes we see. Each of these can result in personal liability to the beneficiaries.

Agent Under a Financial Power of Attorney

If someone has named you as their agent under a durable financial power of attorney, you have the authority to manage their financial affairs when they cannot do so themselves. In Pennsylvania, a durable power of attorney under 20 Pa.C.S. § 5601 remains effective even after the principal becomes incapacitated — which is precisely the scenario it's designed for.

When Your Authority Begins

This depends on how the document is drafted. A "springing" power of attorney only takes effect when the principal becomes incapacitated (usually requiring a physician's certification). An "immediate" power of attorney is effective as soon as it's signed, though the expectation is that you won't use it unless needed. Most modern estate plans use immediate powers with the understanding that the agent will act only when necessary.

Your Core Duties

Act within your authority. The power of attorney document specifies what you can and cannot do. Some grant broad authority over all financial matters; others are limited to specific transactions. Read the document carefully — exceeding your authority can expose you to liability and may void the transaction.

Keep the principal's assets separate. Never commingle the principal's money with your own. Maintain separate accounts and clear records of every transaction. Even well-intentioned commingling (such as depositing the principal's Social Security check into your joint account "for convenience") creates legal problems.

Act in the principal's interest. You must manage their affairs as they would want them managed, not as you think they should be managed. This means paying their bills, maintaining their property, and preserving their assets — not making gifts to yourself or family members unless the document specifically authorizes it.

Keep meticulous records. If you are ever called upon to account for your actions — by the principal, by other family members, or by a court — your records are your defense. Keep receipts, bank statements, a written log of decisions, and copies of all correspondence.

What You Cannot Do (Without Specific Authorization)

Make gifts from the principal's assets, change beneficiary designations, create or modify trusts, or delegate your authority to someone else. These require specific language in the power of attorney document. If the document doesn't address it, assume you can't do it.

Healthcare Agent

A healthcare agent (sometimes called a healthcare proxy or surrogate) is named in a healthcare power of attorney to make medical decisions when the principal cannot. In Pennsylvania, this authority is governed by 20 Pa.C.S. § 5461 and the Advance Directive for Health Care Act.

When Your Authority Begins

Your authority activates when the principal's attending physician determines they are unable to make or communicate healthcare decisions. Until that point, the principal makes their own medical choices regardless of what the document says.

Your Core Duties

Follow the principal's wishes. If the principal has a living will or advance directive that states their preferences about life-sustaining treatment, pain management, or specific procedures, you must follow those instructions. Your personal beliefs about what's "right" are not relevant — your job is to honor their documented choices.

Substituted judgment. For decisions not covered by the advance directive, you must make the decision the principal would have made if they could decide for themselves. This is based on their known values, beliefs, and prior statements about their care preferences.

Best interest. If you have no information about what the principal would have wanted, you make the decision that is in their best medical interest based on the information available from their healthcare providers.

HIPAA access. A properly drafted healthcare power of attorney includes a HIPAA authorization allowing you to access the principal's medical records. Without this, healthcare providers may refuse to share information with you, making it impossible to make informed decisions.

Practical Considerations

Keep a copy of the healthcare power of attorney accessible at all times — in your phone, in the principal's medical chart, and with their primary care physician. In an emergency, you'll need to produce the document quickly. Familiarize yourself with the principal's wishes before a crisis occurs. Have the hard conversations while they can still participate.

Personal Liability — What's at Stake

The legal standard for fiduciary conduct in Pennsylvania is not "did you try your best" — it's "did you act the way a reasonable, prudent person would have acted in the same circumstances?" Good intentions do not protect you from a surcharge action if you made objectively unreasonable decisions.

Executors can be personally liable for paying debts out of the proper order of priority, distributing assets before all taxes are paid, failing to invest estate funds prudently during administration, or making distributions to beneficiaries that cannot be recovered if a creditor claim later arises.

Trustees can be surcharged for investment losses caused by imprudent investment decisions, failure to diversify, self-dealing, unauthorized distributions, or failure to collect income or enforce claims owed to the trust.

POA agents can be held liable for mismanagement, self-dealing, commingling funds, unauthorized gifts, or failure to preserve the principal's assets. Other family members can petition the court to compel an accounting, and if the accounting reveals problems, the agent may be required to repay the principal's estate.

Healthcare agents are generally protected from civil liability for good-faith medical decisions made within the scope of their authority, provided they follow the principal's advance directive and act in accordance with accepted medical standards.

In all fiduciary roles, the most dangerous combination is (1) not understanding your obligations and (2) not keeping records. If a dispute arises and you cannot produce documentation showing what you did, why you did it, and that it was reasonable, the court will not give you the benefit of the doubt.

When to Hire an Attorney

Not every fiduciary needs an attorney for every decision. But certain situations almost always benefit from professional guidance:

You should consult an attorney if:

The cost of legal guidance early in the process is almost always less than the cost of fixing problems caused by well-intentioned but incorrect decisions. In Pennsylvania, executor and trustee fees — including the cost of legal counsel — are paid from the estate or trust, not from your personal funds.

This guide is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Fiduciary obligations depend on the specific terms of the governing document and the facts of your situation. Consult a licensed Pennsylvania attorney for guidance specific to your role.